Blog · Measurement

Email marketing reporting for clients: what to lead with now that open rates mislead

Many email marketing reports still lead with open rates, but Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection stops senders seeing whether an email was opened by anyone who turns it on. This guide builds the client report around the numbers that still hold: clicks, conversions and revenue tracked with UTMs, list health, and spam rates from Google’s and Yahoo’s own tools.

What is email marketing reporting?

Email marketing reporting is the regular summary of what an email programme produced: how many emails reached people, what they did next, what it was worth to the business, and how healthy the list and the sending reputation are. For an agency, it is also how the client sees the value of the work.

The pages that rank for this topic, such as Campaign Monitor’s guide and Litmus’s reporting template, explain the metrics well. This guide is about the client report: which numbers to lead with now that opens are unreliable, how to tie email to revenue, and how to report deliverability from the mailbox providers’ own tools. The wider process of reporting to clients is in client reporting for agencies.

Why open rates mislead

An open is recorded when a small tracking image in the email loads. That was always an imperfect signal, since some people read emails with images turned off. It is now much weaker.

Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection guide says the feature hides the recipient’s IP address and prevents senders from seeing whether they have opened the email. For recipients using it, the open figure in an email platform no longer tells you whether a person read the message.

Platforms also filter automated activity. HubSpot’s email analysis guide notes that opens may be excluded for bot filtering or privacy screening, or not registered at all when the recipient does not load images. So the open rate a client sees can be inflated by privacy features, deflated by filtering, and missing people who read without images, all at once.

That does not make opens useless. A sudden fall can still point to a delivery problem, and the trend over months can still say something. But open rate should not lead a report, decide a subject-line test on its own, or be compared across clients whose subscribers use different email apps.

Where opens can still help

Open data is not worthless; it is just not a measure of reading. A few uses survive.

  • Spotting a delivery problem. A sudden collapse in opens from one mailbox provider, such as Gmail, can be the first visible sign that its users are no longer receiving the email in their inbox.
  • Watching a long trend. A gradual change over many months, on the same list and the same platform, can still say something, as long as nobody reads a single month’s change as a result.
  • Finding inactive subscribers. Combined with clicks, a long absence of any activity helps identify people to re-engage or remove, though some of them may simply read with images off.

In each case, the open figure prompts a question; another number answers it.

The metrics that still hold

Most email metrics are unaffected by privacy features. These are the ones to build the report on.

Email metrics: what each tells you, and how far to trust it
Metric What it tells you How far to trust it
Delivered Messages accepted by the receiving servers Reliable; it is not the same as reaching the inbox
Open rate Messages where the tracking image loaded Weak: privacy features and bot filtering distort it
Click rate Recipients who clicked a link Good, after the platform filters bot clicks
Conversions and revenue Actions on the site after a click, tracked with UTMs Good, if tracking is set up and checked
Unsubscribe rate Recipients who opted out Reliable, and an early warning about content or frequency
Spam complaint rate Recipients who marked the email as spam Reliable in Google’s and Yahoo’s own tools; platform figures can differ
List growth New subscribers minus those lost Reliable; shows whether the list is a growing asset

Click-to-open rate, clicks divided by opens, inherits the problem with opens, because its denominator is the unreliable number. Click rate against delivered emails is the safer comparison from month to month.

The numbers to lead with

A good email report starts with what the email was worth, then explains it. The calculator works out the core figures for one campaign or one month.

The numbers to lead an email report with

Enter one campaign or one month. The defaults are an example, not a benchmark.

Click rate2.5%Unique clicks / delivered
Conversion rate from clicks8.0%Conversions / unique clicks
Revenue per 1,000 delivered$160Revenue / delivered x 1,000
Unsubscribe rate (%)0.15Unsubscribes / delivered, as a percentage
Complaint rate in the platform (%)0.02Complaints / delivered, as a percentage; Google and Yahoo calculate theirs differently
Example figures. Conversions and revenue come from analytics with UTM-tagged links, not from opens. Google and Yahoo measure spam rates in their own tools, on their own basis, so check those as well as the platform figure.

With the example figures, 250 unique clicks from 10,000 delivered is a 2.5% click rate. Twenty conversions from 250 clicks is 8%, and $1,600 of revenue is $160 per 1,000 emails delivered. Unsubscribes are 0.15% and complaints in the platform 0.02%. Revenue per 1,000 delivered is the most useful single figure for an online seller, because it stays comparable when the list grows or shrinks.

Which number leads?

Which number should lead the client’s email report?
Does the client sell online, with revenue tracked in analytics?
Yes
Revenue from email, with revenue per 1,000 delivered as the comparable figure from month to month.
No
Does email lead to enquiries, bookings or sign-ups you can count?
Yes
Conversions from email, such as enquiries or bookings, tracked through UTM-tagged links.
No
Clicks and list health. Click rate, list growth and unsubscribes, with a plan to track a business result.
Open rate does not lead in any branch. It can stay in the report as a rough trend, labelled as such.

Tie email to revenue with UTMs

Email platforms report clicks; the business result happens on the website, in the shop or in the CRM. To connect the two, every link in every email needs UTM parameters, so analytics can attribute the visit, and what follows, to the right campaign.

  • One naming convention. The same source, medium and campaign names for every email, so reports do not split one programme three ways. The UTM builder keeps them consistent.
  • Automatic tagging where the platform offers it. Most email platforms can add UTMs to every link; check what they add and that it matches your convention.
  • Conversions set up in analytics. Purchases, enquiries or bookings marked as key events, so email visits that convert are counted. The GA4 audit guide covers checking this.
  • The CRM for leads. For lead generation, the CRM shows which email leads became customers, which analytics cannot.

Analytics will often credit email with less than the email platform claims, because they count differently. Choose analytics as the source for the business result, say so in the report, and keep the platform for the email-level detail.

Report deliverability from the mailbox providers’ own tools

Deliverability, whether email reaches the inbox rather than spam, decides every other number. The email platform shows bounces and its own complaint count; the mailbox providers show how they see the sender.

  • Google Postmaster Tools. Google’s Postmaster Tools has dashboards for spam rate, reputation, authentication and delivery errors for email sent to personal Gmail accounts. Its data applies only to personal Gmail addresses, so it is a sample, not the whole list.
  • Google’s spam-rate limit. Google’s sender guidelines ask senders to keep spam rates reported in Postmaster Tools below 0.3%.
  • Yahoo’s complaint feedback loop. Yahoo’s best practices ask bulk senders to stay below 0.3% and use its complaint feedback loop to monitor complaints. Yahoo notes that it calculates spam rate on mail delivered to the inbox, so its figure will differ from a platform’s.

Put the Postmaster spam rate in the report each month, with the 0.3% line beside it. A rising rate is worth explaining before it becomes a delivery problem. The sending rules behind it, authentication and one-click unsubscribe among them, are part of the set-up behind any email programme.

Bounces, and what they say

A bounce is an email the receiving server would not accept. The report should show the bounce rate and, when it moves, why.

  • Hard bounces. Permanent failures, such as an address that does not exist. Those addresses should be removed, which most platforms do automatically. A spike usually means a batch of old or bought addresses reached the list.
  • Soft bounces. Temporary failures, such as a full mailbox or a server that is briefly unavailable. A few are normal; a rising number from one mailbox provider can be the first sign that it is throttling or rejecting your mail.
  • Blocks. Rejections because of the sender’s reputation or authentication. These are the ones to investigate the same day.

Bounces are counted before anything reaches an inbox, so they are unaffected by privacy features and among the most dependable numbers in the report.

List health

The list is the asset the client is paying to build. A report should show whether it is growing and whether it is healthy.

  • Growth. New subscribers, minus unsubscribes, bounces and removals, for the period.
  • Sources. Where new subscribers came from, so the client knows which forms and offers work.
  • Unsubscribes by email. An email with far more unsubscribes than usual says something about its content or its audience.
  • Inactive subscribers. People who have not clicked in a long time. Removing or re-engaging them protects deliverability, but agree the rule with the client first.

Campaigns and automations are different

Campaigns are one-off sends, such as a newsletter or a promotion. Automations are the emails that send themselves: a welcome series, an abandoned-cart reminder, a follow-up after a purchase. They do different jobs and should be reported separately.

  • Campaigns. Report each send: delivered, clicks, conversions, revenue and unsubscribes, with a line on what was tested and what was learned.
  • Automations. Report each flow over the month, not each email: how many people entered it, how many completed it, and what it produced. Automations can produce a steady share of revenue that a campaign-only report misses.

Showing the two side by side helps clients see where the value comes from, which is often not the newsletter they spend the most time on.

Ecommerce and lead generation need different reports

The lead number depends on what the email is for, and that changes what the rest of the report shows.

  • Ecommerce. Lead with revenue and revenue per 1,000 delivered. Show orders and average order value from email, and separate automated flows, such as abandoned-cart and post-purchase emails, from promotional campaigns.
  • Lead generation. Lead with enquiries, bookings or sign-ups from email, then follow them into the CRM: how many became opportunities and customers. Email’s value often shows up weeks later, so report on a rolling quarter as well as the month.
  • Publishing and newsletters. Where the email is the product, list growth, clicks to content and paid subscriptions matter more than revenue per send.

Agree the lead number with the client before the first report. Changing it later looks like moving the goalposts, even when the reason is good.

A worked example: one month, two reports

Take the calculator’s example month, with one more hypothetical figure: the platform reports a 45% open rate, up from 38% the month before.

A report that leads with opens says email improved sharply. But the change may reflect nothing more than a larger share of the list using Apple Mail, or a change in how the platform filters bot activity. Nobody can tell from the open rate alone.

A report that leads with the business result says something the client can act on: $1,600 of revenue from email, or $160 per 1,000 delivered, from a 2.5% click rate and an 8% conversion rate on those clicks, with unsubscribes at 0.15% and complaints well below Google’s 0.3% line. If revenue per 1,000 delivered rose from the month before, that is a real improvement; if it fell while opens rose, the opens were never the story.

How often to report email

Monthly suits most clients: long enough for automations to show a pattern, short enough to change course. Within the month, a short note after each major campaign keeps the client informed without a full report.

Check deliverability more often than you report it. A weekly look at bounces, complaints and the Postmaster spam rate catches problems before the monthly report, and before they affect the next campaign. A quarterly review is the place to look at list growth, inactive subscribers and whether the lead number is still the right one.

Explaining the change to a client

Clients used to open rates may see their removal as hiding something. Explain it once, in writing, before the first report that leaves them out of the summary.

A short note is enough: some email apps, including Apple Mail with Mail Privacy Protection turned on, stop senders seeing whether an email was opened, and platforms filter some opens as automated, so open rate no longer measures what it used to. The report will lead with what the emails produced, and keep open rate in the detail as a rough trend. Link to Apple’s own explanation so the client can read it for themselves.

A one-page email report for clients

  1. Summary. Two or three sentences: what email produced this period against the target, the main reason, and what changes next.
  2. The lead number. Revenue, conversions or clicks, with last period and the same period last year.
  3. Campaigns. Each send in one line: what it was, clicks, conversions or revenue, and unsubscribes.
  4. Automations. Each flow: entries, completions and what it produced.
  5. List and deliverability. List growth, unsubscribe rate, complaint rate, and the Postmaster spam rate against 0.3%.
  6. Next month. The sends planned, the test to run, and any decision needed from the client.

Keep open rate out of the summary. If the client is used to seeing it, include it in the detail with a one-line note on why it is no longer reliable, and explain it once, in writing, rather than every month. The same structure, applied to paid search, is in the PPC reporting guide.

Comparing with benchmarks

Email benchmarks are published by several platforms, and clients often ask how they compare. Be careful: open rates in benchmark reports carry the same privacy distortion, and each platform’s customers differ by industry, list size and how they collect subscribers.

The better comparison is the client’s own history: this month against last month and the same month last year, on click rate, revenue per 1,000 delivered and unsubscribes. Use outside benchmarks as a rough sense of range, if at all, and never as a target. How to read published benchmarks without being misled is covered in conversion rate benchmarks by industry, and choosing which numbers to report at all is in the marketing metrics worth tracking.

Testing, and what to report about it

Subject-line tests judged on opens are now unreliable for the same reason open rates are. Test on clicks or conversions instead, and accept that this needs larger lists or longer tests.

  • Test one thing at a time. Subject line, offer, layout or send time, not all four.
  • Judge on clicks or conversions. Not opens.
  • Report the result either way. A test that made no difference is still a result.
  • Keep a log. What was tested, when and what it showed, so the next test builds on it.

Reporting email under an agency’s brand

Agencies that resell email marketing usually send the report under their own name. The data should stay in the client’s own email platform and analytics, and the report should follow the same rules: business result first, opens labelled, deliverability from the providers’ tools. The partner side of that work is on the white-label email marketing page.

Common email reporting mistakes

  • Leading with open rate. The number least likely to mean what the client thinks.
  • Judging subject-line tests on opens. The winner may simply be the version Apple Mail users received more of.
  • No UTMs. Email’s revenue disappears into direct or unknown traffic.
  • Only reporting campaigns. Automations do much of the work and get none of the credit.
  • Ignoring complaints. A rising spam rate is invisible in the platform’s headline numbers until delivery suffers.
  • Comparing with another platform’s benchmark. Different customers, different counting, different privacy effects.
  • No next steps. A report that describes the past and says nothing about the next send.

The email reporting checklist

The checklist covers the set-up once, then each report.

The email reporting checklist
Set-up
Every report
Every quarter
Ticks are saved in your browser.

If you would rather have the email programme run and reported for you, my email marketing service reports this way: revenue and clicks first, deliverability from the mailbox providers’ tools, and opens labelled for what they are.

The short version

Lead an email report with revenue or conversions tracked through UTM-tagged links, then clicks, unsubscribes, complaints and list growth. Treat open rate as a rough trend at best, because Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection hides opens and platforms filter bot activity. Check spam rates in Google Postmaster Tools and keep them below the 0.3% Google and Yahoo set for bulk senders.

Operator note

I lead email reports with what the emails earned, not with opens. A number the client cannot trust should not be the first thing they read.

The automation report is often the one that surprises clients. The emails nobody thinks about can carry a large share of the revenue.

Frequently asked

What should an email marketing report include?
A short summary, the lead number (revenue, conversions or clicks), each campaign and automation, list growth, unsubscribe and complaint rates, the spam rate from Google Postmaster Tools, and what changes next month.
Are email open rates still accurate?
Not reliably. Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection prevents senders from seeing whether an email was opened, and platforms filter some opens as bot activity. Treat open rate as a rough trend, not a lead metric.
What is a good email click rate?
Compare against the client’s own history rather than a general benchmark. Benchmarks vary by platform, industry and list, and many are built on different counting methods.
How do I track revenue from email marketing?
Add UTM parameters to every link, mark purchases or enquiries as key events in analytics, and report the revenue or conversions analytics attributes to email.
What spam complaint rate is too high?
Google asks senders to keep spam rates reported in Postmaster Tools below 0.3%, and Yahoo asks bulk senders to stay below 0.3%. A rising rate below that line is still worth explaining.
What is Google Postmaster Tools?
Google’s free dashboards for senders, showing spam rate, reputation, authentication and delivery errors for email sent to personal Gmail accounts.
Should I report campaigns and automations separately?
Yes. Campaigns are one-off sends; automations run continuously. Report each flow over the month, so its steady contribution is visible.
Related reading
Client reporting for agencies: what it costs, why the numbers disagree, and what clients read PPC reporting: the KPIs that matter, a one-page client report and Google’s rules GA4 audit: a checklist for agencies, in the order that saves data
Working on this yourself?

I have 3 client slots open for Q4 2026. If this raised a question about your own situation, or you want help with it, send it over.

Say hello